660°
Submitted by -Mezzo- 601d ago | opinion piece

Plasma vs. LCD vs. LED: Which HDTV Type is Best?

PC Mag - For a long time, it was tough to call, but today's rapidly evolving technologies have made it easier to crown a winner in the HDTV display wars. (TV, Video)

-Mezzo-  +   601d ago
I stumbled upon this article today while searching 'LCD vs Plasma' in google, I'll be buying a new TV soon and even after reading this article i am not so sure which 1 to get.

I browsed a few local stores and narrowed it down to 2 choices.

A 42" LG LED & A Panasonic's 55" 3D Plasma - but i'm not sure which 1 to get as both of them cost the same.

I'll be using it for Gaming mostly.
------------------

Help will be appreciated guys.
Erudito87  +   601d ago
it depends on the room if you have a room with lots of natural light go for led as they're brighter but if there is no natural light or if you game at night or can control the light easily go for a plasma. id go for a Samsung led or a Panasonic plasma (both cases make sure its 1080p) lg dont usually have that good colour reproductions(in the store they use very controlled environments where the videos are suited for the very saturated colour profiles they use) whats the model number of the 55 inch panasonic?
wishingW3L  +   601d ago
at this point TVs have such a high contrast that unless you have a really incredible eye I doubt you'll see a difference between TV's these days; beside temp color of-course. There will always be TVs that look bluer (Samsung) or more reddish (Panasonic) than others and I always go for the reddish ones because the colors look more natural.

Old HDTV's had the problem with lag and ghosting and with the new ones is the dejudder. So what you really need to look into when buying a new TV is not the contrast and color but which one does the best job at smoothing the annoying dejuddering effect. And believe me, if you haven't notice it already, most PS3/Xbox games are at 30 frames and they try to soften the effect with camera based blur and stuff but it doesn't work that well if you ask me. When you move the camera around the evil dejudder is always there ruining the image and making your eyes hurt. And the lower the frame-rate the worse it gets so, it is a real problem for movies which are filmed at 24 frames.

http://youtu.be/j3ydVKYE9fM

And yes, 240hz fixes it and it's incredibly good for movies but for games it ads tons of lag to the controller and every game will feel heavy like Killzone 2. So concentrate on high-quality panels that do it natively without the help of that gimmick.

Plasma panels > LCD/LED until new tech like OLED comes out.
#1.2 (Edited 601d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(4) | Report | Reply
Baka-akaB  +   600d ago
It's still a problem if you love fighting games , especially 2d styled ones .

Not only are colours more natural on plasma , but you lose the lag , at least on the excellent brands and models , like most Panasonic viera plasmas .
Kur0  +   600d ago
Buy a Plasma. Its cheaper, better image quality, no ghosting or judder so better for gaming.
black911  +   600d ago
I have a Samsung PN51E8000(Rate IT). For gaming on my PS3 and watching Bluray and Tv in HD. Amazing. Just rate it and let me know if I made a good choice.
level 360  +   600d ago
Definite need to know - Plasma emits more heats plus consumes more electricity and are heavier than LED/LCD screens.

So if you're a gamer and are concerned with efficiency go for the LED/LCD. Period.

Also before they said Plasma has a more natural/softer color palette but today LED/LCD has mostly overcome that problem.
Baka-akaB  +   600d ago
It's better but far from overcome . At least unless you go for higher end models .

Black are still way better on some plasma models , again especially panasonic , and less lag is a definitive advantage for a gamer over electricity consumption
DarkSavior  +   600d ago
Yeah. No
maxpoweraff  +   600d ago
I've always been a Vizio fan myself. I've been through a number of TVs over the years because I usually keep them on all the time. Its always hard to pick a new TV because of all the different specs and features that are constantly coming out . Pricing for what features the TV has is a big issue I find myself struggling with. One thing I always do is check reviews and pricing on sites like www.tvrevs.com or other sources and check out some reviews on the brand your thinking about getting. Just my two cents.
steven83r  +   600d ago
I have a 50" Panasonic Plasma i purchased in 08 and it's amazing with bluray and games. The black looks a lot better on plasma as well as color when watching blu ray. Plasma also has higher refresh rate and doesn't have that annoying (to me) soap opera subdrive or whatever (insert company) calls it. Although when the sun is shining through the window i cannot watch tv. My LED is also great for games and movies but doesn't look as vibrant as my plasma. Now top of the line LED is another thing as well as a 2k price tag.
BryanBegins  +   600d ago
I personnally like the frame extrapolation process (what you clal the soap opera effect). I think it makes sports look better, and blu-ray are crazy good. But I know I'm in the minority here (just look at the reactions from the 48 FPS for the Hobbit lol).

But frame-extrapolation has a clear advantage for gaming. For fast games such as Burnout or Infamous (when you run), the LG trumotion improves the game considerably, everything is so smooth, it's like playing at 60-120fps. If I turn it off, I notice it right away.

If you game, you should go with LED anyway. You can always turn some of the video processing off.
#5.1 (Edited 600d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(3) | Report | Reply
Gohadouken  +   600d ago
Not really . It has yet to provide any advantages over other solutions like current and high end plasma , for gaming i mean .

You can use the same IFC and extra motion effects on those screens , the color are more vibrant and natural , blacks are way better .

And most of all , led/lcd screens still got high input lag even with game modes or effects desactivated .

Most viera Panasonic sets are also usually the best gaming 3d sets , aside from Sharp's .
#5.1.1 (Edited 600d ago ) | Agree(1) | Disagree(1) | Report
The_Infected  +   600d ago
Sony Crystal LED looks amazing.
dennett316  +   600d ago
I liked the picture quality of plasma, but the image retention did start to bother me. It's only temporary, and much better than it used to be, but my eye seemed to constantly notice it and it distracted from what I was watching.

A decent LCD is my preferred choice now, preferably with backlit LED as Edge lit LED is often quite flakey and can provide unwanted effects. I have a decent edge lit LED at the moment, but the last two before that were uneven.

My advice is always try to see the TV in the store, ask them to demo the set with a variety of material, and even take your game console down with you to test for lag in the gaming mode...if they want a sale, they should have no problem letting you test this out.
wastedcells  +   600d ago
Just got a Panasonic 60" gt series plasma. My first plasma and it's amazing.... 600hrz. Kills both my LCD and LED tvs. No regrets.
Hoisin07  +   600d ago
Like many others have already said, Panasonic plasma's are absolutely amazing. I have a 46" ST30 series myself. The extremely low input lag is a must for gaming. Image retention is only a problem during the first hundred hours or so.

Also, screen uniformity is much better on plasma sets. Most LCD and LED sets I've tried out are prone to blotches of light leakage. It's so distracting especially when watching movies at night.
kingPoS  +   597d ago
I'd get a plasma myself if I knew it wouldn't burn-in the HUD from various games. Have plasma's overcome that hurtle yet?
#9.1 (Edited 597d ago ) | Agree(0) | Disagree(0) | Report | Reply
MEsoJD  +   600d ago
Plasmas have the best picture. Mmhm... I wish I owned an Elite.

Add comment

You need to be registered to add comments. Register here or login
Remember
New stories
30°

Twitter Acquires Password Security Startup Mitro, Open Sources Its Product

23m ago - Twitter is acquiring a small password security startup called Mitro for its New York office. Mitr... | Software
30°

Apple letting go of redundant Beats employees

24m ago - Report says some Beats employees won’t be part of the company now that it is to become a unit of... | Industry